[theme-reviewers] Admin Opinion Needed

[Chip Bennett]

For future reference, such discussion should remain in-ticket, unless it
need to be discussed on the mail-list.

If you need a second opinion on a review, just ask in-ticket, or CC one of
the admins on the ticket. Failing that, you're welcome to email the list to
ask for a second opinion, but please leave actual discussion of the
underlying issue in the ticket.


On Sat, Jul 13, 2013 at 2:14 PM, Kenneth Bell <webdesignlayer at outlook.com>wrote:

> We need an Opinion by Admins on the following ticket,
>
> http://themes.trac.wordpress.org/ticket/12930
>
> *According to Reviewer Opinion:*
>
> - This theme is almost totally identical to the theme Contango, which is
> already present in the repository.
>
> *Our Response:*
>
> - The design of our theme "Enzyme" is totally different. Our argument is
> supported on the following key points,
>
> *About Design*
>
> 1. Our layout is different as compared to Contango - Please see by
> yourself.
> 2. Contango has big space for "Post Dates" in its design consistency while
> we have arranged Post Meta, Post Titles etc in totally different way.
> 3. Our menu placement is at the side of Logo while Contango support it
> below the header.
> 4. We have also several different elements like featured
> image, typography, color scheme etc.
>
> *About Code*
>
> 1. Yes, we have used the same code base as it is clean and easy to
> understand.
> 2. We are also planning to extend the code base by integrating new options
> in the future like Front Page, Slider etc so we cannot treat our theme as
> Child Theme of Contango.
>
> *Our Question*
>
> 1. Is it **REQUIRED** to write our own code ( re-invent the wheel ) OR we
> cannot use Contango or any other code of theme like "Twenty Eleven" to
> deliver our own creation.
> 2. Our design is totally different - and it is still **REQUIRED** to bring
> some more changes to make it more unique.
>
> We need help from admins or any other expert reviewers.
> Waiting for response.
> Take Care
>
> _______________________________________________
> theme-reviewers mailing list
> theme-reviewers at lists.wordpress.org
> http://lists.wordpress.org/mailman/listinfo/theme-reviewers
>
>
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.wordpress.org/pipermail/theme-reviewers/attachments/20130713/b5f43ce2/attachment.html>